Best & Worst Drugstore Liquid Liners

Felt Tip / Marker Style Eyeliners 

Intial Swatches - not in ranked order (Left to Right): Wet n Wild Mega Eyes, Revlon Colorstay Liquid Eye Pen, Rimmel Scandaleyes Thick & Thin, Maybelline Line Stiletto, Essence, L'Oreal Lineur Intense, L'Oreal Infallible Super Slim, Milani Eye Tech Extreme, CoverGirl Bombshell Intense, Jordana Fabuliner, NYX Super Skinny Marker, Physicians Formula Eye Booster, Milani Ultrafine Liquid 

 After applying water

After applying soap & water

Ranking (from worst to best):

13. Wet n Wild Mega Eyes Defining Marker ~ Black 

Avail. in 1 shade ~ $3.99

12. Revlon Colorstay Liquid Eye Pen ~ Blackest Black

Avail. in 3 shades ~ $8.99

11. Rimmel Scandaleyes Thick & Thin Eyeliner ~ Black

Avail. in 1 shade ~ $5.49

10. Maybelline Line Stiletto ~ Blackest Black 

Avail. in 2 shades ~ $7.99

9. L'Oreal Lineur Intense ~ Carbon Black

Avail. in 3 shades ~ $8.99

8. Essence Eyeliner Pen ~ Black

Avail. in 1 shade ~ $2.99

7. CoverGirl Bombshell Intense ~ Pitch Black

Avail. in 2 shades ~ $8.99

6. NYX Super Skinny Marker ~ Carbon Black

Avail. in 1 shade ~ $8.99

5. Milani Eye Tech Extreme ~ Blackest Black

Avail. in 1 shade ~ $7.99

4. L'Oreal Infallible Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner ~ Black

Avail. in 1 shade ~ $7.99

3. Jordana Fabuliner ~ Black

Avail. in 2 shades ~ $2.99

2. Milani Ultra Fine Liquid Eyeliner ~ Prismatic Purple

(Darkest shade is called Black Vinyl)

Avail. in 5 shades ~ $8.99 (largest color selection)

1. Physicians Formula Eye Booster 2-in-1 Lash Boosting Eyeliner + Serum 

Avail. in 3 shades ~ $10.99

Brush & Ink Well Eyeliners

Intial Swatches - not in ranked order (Left to Right): Maybelline Ultra Liner Waterproof, ELF Liquid Liner, Wet n Wild Mega Liquid Liner, NYC Liquid Liner, Rimmel Glam Eyes Professional Eyeliner, Revlon Colorstay Liquid Liner

  After applying water

After applying soap & water

Ranking (from worst to best):

6. Revlon Colorstay Liquid Liner ~ Blackest Black

Avail. in 1 shade ~ $7.99

5. Wet n Wild MegaLiner Liquid Eyeliner ~ Black

Avail. in 5 shades ~ $2.99

4. ELF Liquid Eyeliner ~ Black

Avail. in 7 shades ~ $1.00 (largest color selection)

3. Rimmel Glam Eyes Liquid Eyeliner ~ Black Glamour

Avail. in 1 shade ~ $6.49

2. NYC Liquid Eyeliner ~ Black

Avail. in 2 shades ~ $2.99

1. Maybelline Ultra Liner Waterproof ~ Black

Avail. in 2 shades ~ $6.99